Which of our mushrooms should you cook?
We grow lion's mane, oyster, chestnut, and golden enoki on our farm in Winston-Salem. This page puts the notes from each guide in one place so we can pick a mushroom for the pan we have in mind.
Side by side
| Mushroom | Taste | Texture | How we cook it | Fridge life | Grow at home |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lion's mane | Mild and a little sweet raw. After a hard sear it tastes savory. We mostly taste browned mushroom and butter. | Soft teeth on the outside. Dense flesh that shreds into strands. | Hard sear, as a steak or shredded into a pan. A boil makes it soft and watery. | About two more weeks in a kraft paper bag, while it is still white and springy. | Easy with a kit. Harder from scratch. |
| Oyster | Mild and a little sweet raw. A hot pan makes them savory. Some clusters smell faintly of anise before they cook. | Soft, fan-shaped caps in a cluster. They cook down fast. | Hot pan in a single layer so the edges brown. A crowded, wet pan steams them. Large caps can be battered and fried. | About two weeks in a paper bag, while the caps are still firm. | Easy with a kit. Harder from scratch. |
| Chestnut | Mild raw. A hot pan brings out a nutty, savory taste. | Small rounded caps on short stems. They stay firm if you do not crowd them, and they release some water as they cook. | Sear or roast hot, mostly whole. Let the water cook off before you add a sauce. We also pickle them. | About 1 week in a paper bag, while the caps are still firm. | Hard. |
| Golden enoki | Mild. Raw, it is light and a little sweet. Warming it brings a mild savory taste, less earthy than a cremini. | Long thin stems and tiny caps. A short cook keeps a little snap. A long simmer turns them soft and limp. | Soup, hot pot, or a quick stir-fry. Add the stems near the end. | About 7 to 10 days in a paper bag, while the stems are still crisp. | Medium to hard. |
Lion's mane
We cook lion's mane when we want a mushroom that can sit in the middle of the plate. Raw, it is mild and faintly sweet. A hard sear browns it, and the dense flesh shreds into strands, which is what makes a steak or a patty work. We skip a boil. Fresh Brown Deer lion's mane keeps in the fridge for about two more weeks in a kraft paper bag. A fruiting kit is the easy start at home. Spawn or a log is a harder project.
Oyster
Oyster mushrooms cook quickly in a pan. Raw, they are mild and a little sweet, and a hot pan makes them savory. The caps are soft and fan-shaped, and they cook down fast, so we give them room if we want the edges to brown. Our blue oysters keep about two weeks in the refrigerator in a paper bag. A kit is easy if you check it each day. Starting from spawn is harder.
Chestnut
Chestnut mushrooms hold their shape in a hot pan and taste a little nutty once the caps brown. The caps are small and rounded. They release some water, so we let that cook off before a sauce. They keep well in the fridge for about 1 week in a paper bag. We rate growing chestnut at home as hard, because the long colonization and fruiting times make a block more likely to dry out or get contaminated.
Golden enoki
Golden enoki is a bundle of long, thin stems and tiny caps. The taste is mild, and the stems stay a little crisp if we cook them briefly in soup, hot pot, or a stir-fry. They keep in the fridge for about 7 to 10 days. We rate growing golden enoki at home as medium to hard.